Don Romans logo

When to Fire a Supervisor: 13 Signs It’s Time

When to Fire a Supervisor: 13 Signs It's Time

It can be challenging to know when to let someone go. But sometimes, the signs are there, and you have to face the facts. If you’re seeing any of the following 13 signs, it may be time to fire your supervisor.

1. The Supervisor is not Meeting Goals or Deadlines

When you’re a business owner, it’s your job to ensure that your employees are productive and meeting goals. But what do you do when your supervisor isn’t meeting those standards? When should you fire a supervisor, and how can you go about doing it?

You should generally consider firing a supervisor if they’re not meeting goals or deadlines, consistently making poor decisions, or creating a toxic work environment. But, of course, it’s not always possible or practical to fire someone, so you may need to explore other options first, such as coaching or counseling. But if those don’t work, it may be time to let the supervisor go.

When you decide to fire a supervisor, it’s essential to do it respectfully and professionally. After all, this is someone who has likely worked hard for your company and may have been dedicated to their job. So take the time to sit down with them and explain why you decide to let them go. Then help them transition out of the company by providing any severance pay or unemployment benefits they may be entitled to.

2. The Supervisor is Micromanaging Employees and Creates a Stressful Work Environment

  • Micromanaging becomes excessive and the work environment becomes more stressful, it may be time to fire the supervisor.
  • Productivity decreases because employees feel they have no autonomy, it may be time to fire the supervisor.
  • Employees leave the company because they can’t stand the work environment anymore, it may be time to fire the supervisor.
  • Customers complain about the quality of service they’re receiving, it may be time to fire the supervisor. In short, when a supervisor is doing more harm than good, it’s time for them to go.

3. The Supervisor is Verbally Abusive or Creates a Hostile Work Environment

When to Fire a Supervisor: The supervisor is verbally abusive or creates a hostile work environment. If you have ever been the victim of verbal abuse or bullying, you know how hurtful and scary it can be. You may feel powerless and that there is nowhere to turn. Unfortunately, many people experience this type of treatment at work. If your supervisor is constantly yelling at you, belittling you, or making you feel like you are worthless, it may be time to take action. First, try to talk to your supervisor about the problem. If that does not work, or if the situation worsens, you may need to consider filing a complaint with HR or quitting your job. No one deserves to be treated like this, and you should not have to put up with it.

4. The Supervisor is Incompetent or Makes Careless Mistakes

When to Fire a Supervisor: If the supervisor is incompetent or makes careless mistakes, it might be time to change. This can be a difficult decision, but it might be the best thing to do if the employees suffer. There are a few signs that it’s time to let go of a supervisor.

  • Employee morale is low.
  • High levels of turnover can also indicate poor leadership.
  • Decreased productivity.

5. There is Evidence of Unethical or Illegal Behavior by the Supervisor

When to Fire a Supervisor: When There’s Evidence of Ethical or Illegal Behavior, no employee is perfect, and even the best supervisor will make a mistake now and then. But what should you do when you suspect that your supervisor is engaging in unethical or even illegal behavior? While it’s never easy to decide to fire someone, it may be the best course of action in this situation. After all, you don’t want to risk being complicit in any unethical or illegal activity. If you have concrete evidence of wrongdoing, sit down with your supervisor and discuss your concerns. If they refuse to listen or try to cover up the behavior, it may be time to take action. Talk to your HR department or another senior manager, and explain the situation. They will help you decide whether or not to fire your supervisor. While it’s a difficult decision, remember that you’re doing what’s best for the company – and yourself.

6. Employees are Openly Discussing Quitting Because of the Supervisor

When to Fire a Supervisor: Employees openly discuss quitting because of the supervisor. When you hear employees talking about how much they hate their job or how they’re going to quit as soon as they find something better, it’s time to take action. These are warning signs that something is seriously wrong within your company, and it’s typically the result of a bad boss. A lousy supervisor is often the number one reason good employees leave an organization. So if you have an employee who is considering quitting because of their supervisor, it’s time to take action. Here are four signs that it’s time to fire a supervisor:

1. The employees are openly discussing quitting because of the supervisor.

2. There is a high turnover rate in the department overseen by the supervisor.

3. Productivity has decreased since the supervisor took over.

4. The quality of work has declined under the supervision of the current manager.  Any one of these four signs is cause for concern, but if you see multiple warning signs, it’s time to take action. Firing a supervisor is never an easy decision, but sometimes it’s necessary.

7. Employees are Constantly Going to HR With Complaints About the Supervisor

When to Fire a Supervisor – When employees are constantly going to HR with complaints about the supervisor, it’s time for a change. The big question is, though, when do you fire the supervisor? We’ve all been there; an employee comes to HR with a complaint about their supervisor. Maybe they’re not being given the proper break times, or perhaps they feel micromanaged. Whatever the case may be, it’s essential to address the issue head-on. But when does it become more than just a simple conflict and warrant firing the supervisor?

When Cleveland Clinic CEO Toby Cosgrove was asked this question, he said that “if somebody is creating an environment where people are anxious or discouraged or unhappy, that’s not tolerated.” When employees feel like they can’t speak up or voice their concerns, it creates a toxic work environment. So, if you’re receiving multiple complaints about a particular supervisor, it might be time to chat with them about their management style. If they’re unwilling or unable to make changes, it might be time to let them go. After all, your goal should be to create a positive and productive work environment for all employees – and that starts with having the suitable supervisors in place.

8. The Supervisor has a High Turnover Rate of Direct Reports

When it comes to managing a team, it’s essential to know when to fire a supervisor. A high turnover rate of direct reports is often a sign that something is wrong with the way the supervisor is leading. If your business is losing good employees because of a high turnover rate, it’s time to take action. When interviewing candidates for a management position, ask about their leadership style and how they would handle a high turnover rate. You want to make sure you’re hiring someone who will be able to manage a team and keep turnover low effectively. If you’re already dealing with a high turnover rate, sit down with the supervisor and discuss what could be causing the problem. If the supervisor is unable or unwilling to make changes, it may be time to let them go.

9. The Supervisor is Resistant to Change

There are a few different times when you should fire a supervisor. The first is if they are resistant to change. In today’s business world, the ability to adapt is crucial. If your supervisor is stuck in their ways and unwilling to try new things, it’s time to let them go. Another reason to fire a supervisor is if they consistently fail to meet deadlines. This failure shows that they’re not capable of managing their team effectively. Finally, if your supervisor constantly creates a hostile environment, it’s time for them to go. Employees shouldn’t have to dread coming to work every day. If your supervisor is making the workplace miserable, it’s time to change.

10. The Supervisor is Uncooperative or Unprofessional

When to fire a supervisor is a difficult question. The answer depends on many factors, such as the severity of the offense, the impact on morale, and the company’s legal liability. It may be best to transfer the supervisor to another department or location in some cases. However, if the problem is severe enough, it may be necessary to take more drastic action. When deciding whether or not to fire a supervisor, it is essential to consult with Human Resources and other members of management. They will be able to guide how to proceed.

11. The Supervisor is not a Team Player

When to fire a supervisor is a difficult question. On the one hand, you don’t want to be hasty and get rid of someone who may be a valuable asset to the company. On the other hand, you don’t want to keep someone on staff who actively hinders productivity. A few key signs indicate it may be time to let a supervisor go. First, if they consistently fail to meet deadlines or take on more projects than they can handle, it’s a sign that they’re not well-organized. Second, if they refuse to delegate tasks or micromanage their team, they don’t trust their employees to do their jobs. Finally, if they regularly clash with other departments or play favorites with certain employees, it’s a sign that they’re not a team player. When supervisors exhibit these behaviors, it’s usually best to let them go.

12. The Supervisor Does not Communicate Effectively

When to Fire a Supervisor: The supervisor does not communicate effectively. When you have a team member who isn’t meeting your expectations, it may be time for a change in leadership. If your staff constantly comes to you with complaints about their supervisor, it’s time to have a serious conversation. When a supervisor is not communicating effectively, it can lead to low morale and high turnover. If you’ve tried to address the issue with the supervisor directly and nothing has changed, it may be time to let them go. When a supervisor is not a good fit for the team, it’s essential to make a change before the situation gets worse.

13. The Supervisor Creates an Atmosphere of Fear or Intimidation

When to Fire a Supervisor: When the supervisor creates an atmosphere of fear or intimidation in the workplace, it may be time for HR to intervene. If an employee reports feeling scared or threatened by their supervisor, that is a red flag that something is wrong. The supervisor may be engaging in verbal or physical harassment, or they may be making threats. Regardless of the specifics, this is not acceptable behavior from a supervisor. If HR is made aware of these complaints, they should investigate immediately. If they find that the supervisor is responsible for creating a hostile work environment, they should be fired. This will send a clear message to other employees that this behavior will not be tolerated.


If you are experiencing any of these signs, it may be time to fire your supervisor. It is important to remember that you are not alone in this decision. Many other employees have likely felt the same way, and HR will probably be on your side if you decide to terminate the supervisor’s employment. Remember to document everything and follow proper protocol when firing a supervisor.